CHEYENNE -- A bill pending in the Wyoming Legislature to cut some state services to illegal immigrants would disrupt families and scare even legal immigrants from seeking help when they need it, opponents of the measure said.
Wyoming is one of several states where lawmakers are seeking to crack down on illegal immigration, citing an absence of federal action on the issue. The Wyoming bill passed the House this week and is pending in the Senate.
House Majority Floor Leader Colin Simpson, the bill's sponsor, said he modeled it after similar legislation enacted in Colorado in 2006.
Simpson said he believes thousands of illegal immigrants in Wyoming now receive benefits. His bill would block them from services ranging from driver's licenses and non-emergency health care to post-secondary education and food assistance.
"When you look at the numbers of what illegal aliens cost America, for one, they're fairly staggering," said Simpson, R-Cody. "And in Wyoming, we have much smaller population, so our numbers are lower. But assuming we had 5,000 illegal aliens who are receiving benefits worth $10,000 apiece, that adds up on an annual basis, and burdens all kinds of the social welfare systems."
Bille Metzger, program director of La Puerta Abierta, a program that works with immigrant families in Jackson, said the group trains adults about government services available for them.
She said many of the immigrants have visas to work in the country, and changing state law to specify that illegal immigrants aren't eligible for government services would hit the entire immigrant community.
"They would not feel comfortable because of insecurity of not knowing how the system works, what would happen to them, how it would affect their life, the lives of their children or family members," Metzger said.
Any deportation of a family member affects the entire immigrant family, including others who are in the state legally, Metzger said.
The Pew Hispanic Center in 2006 estimated that Wyoming has fewer than 10,000 illegal immigrants -- a tiny portion of the roughly 12 million people the group estimates are in the country illegally.
Jack Martin of the Federation for American Immigration Reform, a Washington D.C. group, said his group also estimates that Wyoming's illegal immigrant population is about 5,000 to 10,000.
"It's so small that its not really on the radar screen compared to states like Arizona, Texas or California," said Martin, whose group advocates on tightening immigration laws.
Yet Martin estimated that Wyoming spends about $5 million a year on providing benefits to illegal immigrants.
Sen. Drew Perkins, R-Casper, a co-sponsor of the Wyoming measure, said he and Simpson are concerned that Wyoming could become a haven as other states tighten their illegal immigration laws.
"If you don't keep pace, ultimately, you end up creating a hole, and you end up being the one people go to because they can get those benefits without any kind of scrutiny," Perkins said.
The bill's sponsors said they're not opposed to legal immigration. Perkins pointed out that there's high demand in Wyoming for qualified workers.
In Jackson, many restaurants and hotels are able to provide their immigrant workers short-term visas, Metzger said.
"I know most of them came here on a legal visa, and are trying to maintain their status," she said.
La Puerta Abierta trains 15 immigrant families in language skills as well as how to integrate into U.S. society, without asking about their residency status, Metzger said.
Metzger said her program also helps the immigrants' children, nearly all of them were born in Wyoming.
Rep. Ken Esquibel, D-Cheyenne, was among the minority in the House to vote against the bill.
"I don't really think that we need to be giving services to illegal aliens," Esquibel said. "But if they have kids, and they're in schools, and they're American citizens, it would affect them as far as whether or not the parents were there, and if they've got a job. It would affect whether or not they can put food on the table, and clothes on the backs of the kids."
Reader Comments
Comments to this story.
JanetP wrote on Feb 28, 2008 5:13 AM:
How about a word or two about the effect illegal immigration is having on Americans - and more specifically on the citizens of Wyoming? Don't we count anymore? Should all our efforts and resources be directed toward making illegal immigrants feel 'comfortable' and 'secure?' Indeed they should feel apprehension, just like any other person who has broken the law and fears being discovered.
"
BULL wrote on Feb 28, 2008 9:43 AM:
JAS wrote on Feb 28, 2008 5:32 PM:
BornInTheUSA wrote on Feb 28, 2008 9:45 PM:
frank l kinney wrote on Feb 28, 2008 10:40 PM:
georgewashakie wrote on Feb 29, 2008 9:35 AM:
JAS wrote on Feb 29, 2008 5:40 PM:
georgewashakie wrote on Mar 1, 2008 9:32 AM:
Gunner wrote on Mar 1, 2008 5:16 PM:
Karen wrote on Mar 2, 2008 6:17 AM:
profit wrote on Mar 2, 2008 7:34 AM:
Lamp Lighter wrote on Mar 2, 2008 9:46 AM:
iri4q2 wrote on Mar 2, 2008 10:58 AM:
Delaware Bob wrote on Mar 2, 2008 4:10 PM:
How and why would this scare legal immigrants? Legal residents have NOTHING to be scared of. It's the ILLEGAL ALIENS we must stop from getting benefits they don't deserve or have a right to.
I'm all for the law being passed and the sooner the better. The Oklahoma and Arizona laws are working GREAT!, so I have heard. Schools are less crowded, no more anchor babies, hospitals are no longer overwhelmed and saving the taxpayers lots of money. I have read that crime is down. That's good.
I say pass the law. It's time these ILLEGAL ALIENS go back to their home country and give us our Country back. What is the problem with that?
"
Ricardo wrote on Mar 3, 2008 6:37 AM:
Trixie wrote on Mar 3, 2008 10:06 AM:
Grady wrote on Mar 3, 2008 11:52 AM:
georgewashakie wrote on Mar 3, 2008 1:20 PM:
Tell us again which DFS office was processing benefits for illegal immigrants.
Explain how the Arizona law which is working so well has nothing to do with the legislation you are talking about. By the way, the Arizona law has been held up because of numerous problems.
"Anchor babies" are an invention of people who want to change laws without amending the Constitution.
Look at what the newspapers in Oklahoma have to say about their new law--plenty of problems. "
May wrote on Mar 3, 2008 1:26 PM:
Edna wrote on Mar 3, 2008 3:18 PM:
georgewashakie wrote on Mar 3, 2008 8:23 PM:
I believe that the immigration system is broken and needs to be fixed, as a national policy. I also believe it is tragic to see citizens being strummed by politicians who know how to play the idiot card.
Ask your elected representative where they stood on this bill, and then ask them why the legislature is turned off to the Real ID proposal which would be needed to put teeth in this lbill.
How long has it been since you wrote to Senator Enzi, Senator Barrassso, or Representative Cubin? Try a little accountability--or research. "
Dame wrote on Mar 4, 2008 1:54 PM:
sherri wrote on Mar 4, 2008 2:07 PM:
It is simply good law that will keep Wyoming from becoming not just a safe haven for illegal immigrants, but also for terrorists posing as illegal immigrants. Not to mention the fact that the overwhelming majority of Wyoming's legal residents and citizens want this law on the books.
The misfortunes of illegal immigrants in their native countries is not the responsibility of Wyoming or American taxpayers. We have enough problems of our own without adopting Mexico's or any other country's problems.
Yes, Wyoming will become a safe haven for illegal immigrants and we will end up bearing the burden for most of the rest of the country.
Many other states have already passed similar legislation and those laws are passing constitutional considerations. If Wyoming does not pass this law we will have to absord a hugely disproportionate burden of the costs and all the other problems (cultural, criminal, linguistic, healthcare, education, etc. etc. etc.) because tens of thousands of illegal immigrants will migrate immediately to Wyoming. Many of them already are.
There is just no way to justify making Wyoming taxpayers pay for benefits for individuals who have broken our federal laws, and then demand services that in most cases they have not payed one dime into. By the way the Mexican anchor babies that are born in this country are also by law Mexican citizens and can return to Mexico with their parent(s) at any time. The only hardship that can befall these children is brought upon them and continued by their illegal immigrant parent(s) remaining in this country illegally.
Wyoming's legislature can do The citizens and legal residents of our state a big favor by passing this legislation at this time. Waiting even one more year could make the situation far worse than it is now. During the next year conservative estimates indicate that if Wyoming does not have laws preventing benefits from being given to illegal immigrants, the migration in just 12 months time into the state will be between 11,000 to 18,000 more illegal immigrants. The U.S. department of health and human services released figures last year indicating that 68% of the people identified as illegal immigrants applied for and received public assistance benefits in 39 states. None of these states had laws preventing benefits from being granted to the illegal immigrants at that time. That means without this legislation Wyoming can expect to have an increase of at least 9,860 more persons on public assistance over the next 12 months.
Then there will be the other increased costs such as incarceration, state and local justice processes, and of course educational cost increases which also will include additional bilingual educators. If the state legislature cares in the least about the quality of life in our state they will pass this legislation now.
"
Dame wrote on Mar 4, 2008 2:09 PM:
Albert wrote on Mar 4, 2008 4:47 PM:
macaad wrote on Mar 4, 2008 8:15 PM:
Trace wrote on Mar 5, 2008 8:27 AM:
hvacman wrote on Mar 5, 2008 8:37 AM:
georgewashakie wrote on Mar 5, 2008 9:20 AM:
Would it make any difference if almost half of the "illegals" filled out the paperwork and came into the USA on visas? Ask the INS.
Those who are concerned about drug trafficking and terrorism, show a little support for constructing a fence along the U.S./Canadian border and building a fleet of Coast Guard cutters to station every five miles of coast line, like we have done in Florida for the past forty years. "
Baller wrote on Mar 5, 2008 1:17 PM:
Ben wrote on Mar 5, 2008 10:42 PM:
DONT LISTEN TO THE PHONY ARGUMENT THAT WE CANNOT ROUND ALL THE MILLIONS OF ILLEGALS UP AND DEPORT THEM. WE DON'T HAVE TO! JUST STOP THE BENEFITS AND THE JOBS, AND START PUNISHING THE EMPLOYERS FOR VIOLATING THE LAW BY HIRING ILLEGALS. MOST OF THE ILLEGALS WIILL MIGRATE BACK TO MEXICO ON THEIR OWN OVER THE NEXT TWO OR THREE YEARS! THE GREEDY SLAVE LABOR EMPLOYERS ARE LARGELY RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS, SO START CHANGING STATE GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS TO EXCLUDE THOSE BUSINESSES THAT HIRE ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS.
Wyoming consumers should stop doing business with any company or individuals that are using illegals in their workforce. Boycott them into following the law. If Wyoming's legislators could see first hand what has happened to all the areas in America that have been inundated by these illegals and all the horrendous costs and problems they have created they would pass this bill and other stronger measures in a heartbeat. This is not hysteria or raciscm, it is the plain facts.
Don't let Wyoming become a magnet state for illegals, or everyone living here will be very sorry. Just look at how many comments in support of this law there is compared to the number of comments in favor of illegal immigrants and you will know what Wyoming wants. Just because a large number of people decided to overwhelm our federal law enforcement community with sheer numbers does not mean they should get away with it. The states and local governments have to step in now and help federal law enforcement by adopting local and state laws so that these lawbreakers are not getting benefits which enables them to continue to break the federal law and encourages more of them to come and do so. If you are giving these law breakers jobs, money, and any kind of benefits and services you are aiding and abetting them.
STOP THIS DANGEROUS ILLEGAL INVASION OF OUR COUNTRY AND STATE NOW BEFORE IT IS TO LATE!!! "
Dame wrote on Mar 6, 2008 10:19 AM:
Doris wrote on Mar 6, 2008 11:19 AM:
Some of you are suggesting that we just roll-over and give in to the desires of these foreign criminals. Is this how you lead your life? If so you are a loser and should not have an opinion.
These invaders need to go home and do something about their own corrupt countries rather than come here and trash ours. Those of you that support them need to reevaluate what is right and what is wrong. You seem to have lost your moral compass.
Yes, getting ride of them will be tough, most things worth doing are challenging (remember WWII?). The answer is not to give up and do as dictated to by thugs and their weakling domestic criminal supporters.
"
LKD wrote on Mar 6, 2008 3:25 PM:
Chris wrote on Mar 6, 2008 11:36 PM:
Every part of our country that has been ruined in every way that you can ruin something started out with only a few thousand illegal residents. Very quickly it became several ten thousand illegal residents and the problems exploded. If you take away the jobs and the benefits they will leave. No need to deport them. When you have no way to get money or any other necessity in a country that you have entered illegally, you will go back home to your native country and try to make it a better place to live. And you will take your children with you.
This problem grew exponentially after George W. Bush came into office because he wanted an open border with Mexico due to his family's close personal ties with the people and government of Mexico. Our immigration laws were quite enforceable and still are enforceable, but the chief executive in charge of enforcing our nation's laws refuses to do so. He and a few other people, most of whom are hiding in the shadows, want to unite Canada, Mexico and the United States into a North American Union just like the European Union. They don't even bother trying to lie about it or hide it anymore. They are just going to do this, U.S. constitution be damned, by creating a defacto economic, no borders union of the three countries. This will dilute the standard of living and the quality of life for all Americans, while our less fortunate neighbors, mostly Mexico, reap all the benefits.
And guess what? Your president and your elected representatives never asked you ONCE what you wanted!
I am not waiting around for my state representative and senator to ask me. I am telling you flat out pass this law and represent me, a legal U.S. citizen born in Sheridan, Wyoming who pays taxes at the federal and state levels. If you don't you are sell-outs and cowards and do not deserve to continue to unrepresent me and the rest of our state's legal, tax paying citizens.
"
Julie wrote on Mar 6, 2008 11:57 PM:
Submit a Comment